LSM-ONLINE-LOGO2JPG.jpg (4855 bytes)

Current
Home
Calendar

Back Issues
LSM Issues
LSV Issues

Features
WebNews
Newswire
Throat Doctor
Interviews
Concert Reviews
CD Critics
Books Reviews
PDF Files

Links
Audio
Midi

LSM
About LSM
LSM News
Distribution
Advertising
Guest Book
Contact Us
Site Search
Web Search

On the Aisle

 

[INDEX]


Montreal Symphony Orchestra at Carnegie Hall

By Philip Anson / October 28, 2002
On the Aisle


The Montreal Symphony Orchestra’s annual autumn pilgrimmage to New York’s Carnegie Hall has produced triumphs over the decades. Last year’s Martha Argerich showcase was one of them. But this year was a sad exception, revealing some of the worst playing from the MSO I have ever heard.

The question on everyone’s mind when the MSO took the Carnegie stage on Saturday, Oct. 26 was how it would sound without Charles Dutoit, who quit as the band’s Music Director last April. The answer was worrisome, to judge by the overblown reading of Berlioz's La Damnation de Faust lead by 69-year-old French conductor Michel Plasson.

Instrumental soloists were sloppy and sometimes off-pitch. Sections lacked solidity or coherence. Coordination between sections was unpredictable. The performance as a whole lacked Berliozian style. The MSO’s fabled French touch - the gossamer strings, the airy lightness and lightning response of sections, the purity of woodwind and horn solos, the pert rhythms - was gone. The playing was often deafeningly loud. Plasson was obviously unable to adjust from the dead acoustics of Montreal's Salle Wilfrid Pelletier to the subtle, lively surroundings of Carnegie Hall. Some consolation came from the serviceable vocal soloists: a menacing John Relyea as Mephistifeles, tenor Michael Schade as Faust, and a rather dreary Ruxandra Donose as Marguerite.

But what alarmed me wasn’t the sins Plasson committed, but rather the virtues the MSO omitted. You would expect that after 25 years playing this music under Dutoit the MSO could play French music well, no matter how bad the guest conductor. But the band seemed to have completely forgotten the valuable lessons Dutoit taught them. There seemed to be no collective memory of the performance techniques and qualities associated with Dutoit’s successful performances of this kind of music.

VillaumeThe concert on Sunday Oct. 27 under Emmanuel Villaume (photo left) was much better. Szymanowski’s mystical-impressionistic Third Symphony (“Song of the Night”) was an interesting novelty in the style of Scheonberg's Gurrelieder and Szymanowski's Krol Roger, which the MSO have played in recent seasons. The MSO performed with an accuracy, confidence and coherence totally lacking the previous night. Alas, tenor Jon Garrison was too old for the high solo part. Ravel’s Daphis et Chloé was given a respectable though less idiomatic reading than Dutoit used to give.

Saturday’s concert was well-attended but Sunday’s concert was half empty, the worst attendance I have ever seen at Carnegie Hall. Since bad reviews had not yet appeared, the poor attendance must have been due to a combination of factors: no star soloist, no Dutoit, obscure repertoire, and the general economic downturn which has affected all arts presenters.

Reviews were mixed. The New York Times noted strengths and weaknesses. The Montreal Gazette cheerled for the home team (memo to the Gazette: Emmanuel Villaume is not a “fully unknown French conductor”, he is a regular guest conductor with major US orchestras and he is the artistic director of the Spoleto Festival, the biggest arts festival in the southern USA).

While it is too early to draw conclusions about the effect of Dutoit’s departure on the MSO, the signs are not good. To judge by the Carnegie Hall concerts, the MSO musicians are only as good or bad as their conductor. If this is true, their rejection of Dutoit could mean they have nowhere to go but down, since it will be hard to find a conductor of Dutoit's calibre as the new music director. As Claude Gingras wrote in La Presse on Oct. 23, 2002, Dutoit’s departure could well prove an artistic “catastrophe” for the MSO if they do not find strong leadership soon.



[INDEX]


(c) La Scena Musicale 2001 and Philip Anson